Submission Review/7

Other (7001-7999)

No.	Title	Presenter (first author)	Vote 2 (Phoebe Ayers)	Vote 3 (Deror Lin)	Vote 4 (Guillaume Paumier)	Vote 6 (Caroline Becker)	Vote 7 (Nicolas VIGNERON)	Vote 8 (Léa Lacroix)	Vote 9 (Kiril Simeonovski)	Final Score	Comments
7001	Etytree: A Graphical and Interactive Etymology Dictionary Based on Wiktionary	Epantaleo	10	5	7	8	10	8	7	7.86	Lightning talk lightning talk
7002	Mapping the Communities of Wikimedians in the Philippines	Filipinayzd	8	1	8	7	4	8	1	5.29	Lightning talk Phoebe - I would definitely accept this as a lightning talk (not a 30 min talk) Kiril: yes for poster
7003	Pronunciation remediation	James Salsman	OS	1	OS	OS		OS	OS	0.20	Tutorial Kiril: seems to be out of scope.
7004	Targeted Community Inclusion through 21st February Wiki-Gathering	Username:Tanweer Morshed	10	8	9	9	9	7	5	8.14	Lightning talk Phoebe: yes for lightning talk
7005	Utilisation avancée de l'éditeur visuel	Benoît Evellin / Trizek (WMF)		10	9	10	9	10	7	9.17	Tutorial
7006	Wiki Loves Africa	Islahaddow and Anthere		10	10	10	10	10	10	10.00	Exhibition
7007	WikiFundi : editing Wikipedia offline across Africa	Islahaddow and Anthere	10	10	10	10	10	9	9	9.71	Lightning talk See also 7008 Kiril: very interesting, but short on time. Phoebe: yes for lightning talk
7008	WikiFundi: An Early Deployment in Cape Town	Michael Graaf	10	10	9	10	10	6	9	9.14	Poster See also 7007
7009	Wikipedia Primary School research project poster	Florence Devouard (user:anthere)	10	10	9	8	10	9	9	9.29	Poster
7010	Automatic Deciphering and Digitization Of Ancient Characters (Brahmi, Vattezhuthu And Grantha) Of The Tamil Language From Manuscripts And Inscriptions	E.K.Vellingiriraj (girirajek)		1	3	OS	R3/R7?	OS	OS	1.17	Lightning Talk Kiril: seems to be out of scope. Unsure : 3 for presention but 7 for poster ?
7011	Klexikon the free encyclopedia for children poster	Ziko van Dijk	10	10	9	8	9	7	7	8.57	Poster Phoebe: yes for poster Kiril: +1 to Phoebe; otherwise, out of scope.
7012	Learn how to explain your idea in 60 seconds only!	Elisabeth Mandl, Wikimedia Deutschland		8	6	10	10	7	8	8.17	Workshop - 60 min see also 5010 - same idea, different presenters
7013	Making NeuroTechnology Accessible	Sydney Swaine-Simon		8	OS	4	7	7	4	6.00	Lightning Talk
7014	100womenwikidays to bridge gender gap	Meena gayathri.s		4	7	5	8	7	8	6.50	Lightning Talk
7015	3 million old place names	Susanna Ånäs and Niklas Laxstöm		9	8	6	9	9	7	8.00	Lightning Talk
7016	EduAir	User: Yanstv		3	7	7	5	4	3	4.83	Lightning Talk
7017	Facilitation Skills for Humans	Asaf Bartov		10	9	9	9	4	10	8.50	Workshop - 4 hours. Léa: Both for 7017 and 7019, I don't see the direct link with our movement.
7018	GLAMpipe tutorial	Susanna Ånäs		9	8	7	8	7	7	7.67	Workshop / Tutorial - 60 min. To merge with other GLAM tools introduction?
7019	Conflict Engagement for Humans	Asaf Bartov		6	10	5	9	4	4	6.33	Tutorial - 3 hours; see also 7017 Kiril: yes if merged with 7017.
7020	Making decisions together: Tools for community listening	Edward Galvez		6	7	8	9	6	9	7.50	Workshop - 60 min.
7021	Pirates at work	Peter Gallert (w:User:Pgallert)	10	10	8	8	8	6	7	8.14	Half day - outside; Deror: sounds crazy, but why not?. Léa: serious doubts about the format. Phoebe: I'm not sure if we should set aside specific times for this, but let's set aside some tables in the lounge/hackathon area for this and make it an ongoing birds of a feather.
7022	Wikimedia Foundation’s Language round-table	Runa Bhattacharjee		9	7	7	9	7	7	7.67	Roundtable discussion - 60 min
7023	Wikidata Pink Pony Session	Lea Lacroix (WMDE), Lydia Pintscher (WMDE)		10	10	10	10	COI	10	10.00	Roundtable discussion - 25 min
7024	Wikicheese	Sylvain Boissel and Pierre-Yves Beaudouin		10	10	10	10	10	9	9.83	Poster and Meetup
7025	What is the smallest community that can support a Wikipedia?	Vogone, Ijon, and MF-Warburg		10	9	9	10	8	8	9.00	Roundtable discussion - 25 min
7026	Transl-a-thon: Wikidata in your language	Pymouss, Kvardek du, VIGNERON		10	10	10	COI	10	10	10.00	workshop - 60 min
7027	8 FLOSS tools and 4 hardware for audio, video and image editing for Commons	Subhashish Panigrahi		7	7	7	8	7	7	7.17	workshop - 60 min
7028	A Wikipedia article in multiple languages improved by many Wikipedians at once	Niki Korth		9	10	8	7	7	6	7.83	workshop - 60 min
7029	Hacking our brains for collaboration	Arthur Richards			7	5	7		5	6.00	workshop, 55 min
7030	How good communication can help you talk to reporters, rule the world, and do other cool stuff: An introductory guide to public relations	author			8	10	10		10	9.50	workshop
7031	How to make successful hackathon	Santosh M. Shingare			5	4			OS	4.50	lecture (15 min) Kiril: no clear link to the movement (hackathon is a very broad term) and short on time (preferably at least 30 minutes). VIGNERON : should maybe be a lightning talk?
7032	Introduction to Low Context and High Context: Communicate Effectively Between Cultures	Delphine Ménard			10	10	10		9	9.75	workshop Kiril: definitely yes for a workshop, but employing examples from the movement is highly recommended.
7033	Is Wikimedia A Memory Institution?	Tyng-Ruey Chuang			8	9	7		8	8.00	panel Kiril: who was invited and who confirmed participation?
7034	Submissions/Light the Night Sky: The Issue of Light Pollution	Vasu Jain	OS		OS	OS	OS		OS	OS	lecture or lightning talk
7035	Submissions/Partnerships Clinic: What to do when your partnerships have gone wrong?	Partnerships and Global Reach team, Wikimedia Foundation.			9	8	9		9	8.75	workshop, 60 min
7036	Submissions/User digest/State of Wikimedia Research 2016-2017	Benjamin Mako Hill; co-presenters: Tilman Bayer, Aaron Shaw			9	10	10		10	9.75	lecture
7037	Submissions/Strategy2030	Florence Devouard			COI	7	9		10	8.67	Discussions: strategy discussions to be set up after the strategy proposals. Kiril: support in principle but no-one knows what will be announced at Wikimania.
7038	Submissions/The role of Wikimedia in emergency response	Daniel Mietchen			9	9	8		10	9.00	workshops Kiril: excellent and very useful topic.
7039	Submissions/The role of Wikipedia in the progress of Artificial intelligence	Mahdi Shafiee (sh_mahdi)			8	9	9		8	8.50	poster Kiril: poster is fine for this topic.
7040	Submissions/The Wikipedia Killer	User:Ziko van Dijk			10	6	9		10	8.75	workshop Kiril: great and very interesting way to work upon improving Wikipedia.
7041	Submissions/Using MediaWiki tools and Wikipedia community to crowdsource insights for aging and cancer research	Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD			6	8	6		3	5.75	lecture Kiril: might be very useful for the field of oncology but a bit off-topic take-aways for the attendees; more support for a poster, though.
7042	Submissions/WikiExpedition	Drbug, Niklitov			7	8	9		9	8.25	Poster Kiril: very good and informative topic for poster.