Submission Review/4

From Wikimania
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Legal & Free Culture (4001-4999)

No. Title Presenter (first author) Vote 1 (Marc André Pelletier) Vote 2 (Phoebe Ayers) Vote 3 (Deror Lin) Vote 4 (Guillaume Paumier) Vote 5 (Ellie Young) Vote 6 (Caroline Becker) Vote 7 (Nicolas VIGNERON) Vote 8 (Léa Lacroix) Vote 9 (Kiril Simeonovski) Vote 10 (Orsolya Virág) Vote 11 (Dumisani Ndubane) Vote 12 (Jean-Philippe Béland) Final Score Comments Community Comments Submitter attending?
4001 Fair Use in Australia campaign Wittylama 10 10 9 9 10 9 10 9.57 Lecture Could be in a program w/ 4002
4002 It's alive! The EU copyright reform is coming and will affect Wikipedia. Dimi 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10.00 Lecture: Could be in a program w/ 4001
4003 New Wikimedian Order - How to represent Wikimedia's values in international organisations? John Weitzmann, Dimi Dimitrov 9 10 9 10 9 9 10 9.43 Roundtable - 45
4004 Wikipedia vs. the courts Piotr Sitnik - user:Myopic pattern 5 10 8 10 10 9 10 8.86 Lecture: Submission seems overly broad, doesn't have a clear focus. -- phoebe
4005 Copyright for Dummies BU Rob13 ?? 9 5 4 6 7 4 5.83 Lecture sub but really more of a workshop. Phoebe: I'm torn about this as it's a great topic, but pitched to beginners. If we have a beginner's track, or want to accept some beginner workshops, this would be great.
4006 How the intellectual property regime is killing free knowledge and innovation in the Global South Fernando Otero 8 OS 5 8 ? 5 OS 4.33 Kiril: great and very important topic but, unfortunately, no clear link to the movement; the topic fits very well for a keynote speaker.
VIGNERON: seems too wide, maybe it should be a lightning talk ?
I disagree that this is out of scope. See 4012: very related.-- Phoebe
4007 Political elections - Wikipedia matters Hogne Neteland 9 10 6 5 7 6 6 7.00 Lecture see also 2023 and 2097 - could be combined into a fun panel on elections & Wikipedia -- Phoebe
4008 How does common knowledge sound? My experience uploading audio files to Commons Luis Álvarez / Luisalvaz 10 10 8 6 9 8 7 8.29 Lecture: Submitter submitted as a lightning talk but it's really a lecture. We've gotten many submissions about video over the years; sound is cool too! -- Phoebe
4009 Building Momentum Together: Open Access to Research & Wikimedia Nick Shockey, SPARC 9 9 9 10 8 7 10 8.86 Roundtable: There is a big interest community around OA; having a roundtable/meetup would be good. -- Phoebe
4010 Copyclearing with Wikidata Hanno Lans 9 10 8 9 9 9 8 8.86 Lecture If we don't have room this would make a great poster, too -- Phoebe
4011 How do we encourage reusers to respect CC-BY-SA? WereSpielChequers 6 10 5 8 8 9 7.67 roundtable
see also 5018 Formatted as a panel, but would be better as an actual discussion. Also not sure what the debate is here, exactly. Would people learn anything new? -- Phoebe
4012 Intellectual Property Barriers to GLAM Projects in Global South Rohini Lakshané and Tanveer Hasan 7 7 7 9 8 7 7.50 panel (45 min)
Kiril: who was invited and who confirmed participation? Phoebe: interesting & important topic but the submission is not great. Could be a shorter lecture.
4013 Knowledge for everyone: making access affordable Adele Vrana, Anne Gomez, Jack Rabah, Jan Gerlach, Jorge Vargas, Ravi Ayyakkannu 9 10 9 10 9 10 9.50 roundtable, 55 min - I think this could be a shorter lecture too - Phoebe
4014 Legal Advocacy for the Projects and the Movement Jacob Rogers and Aeryn Palmer (WMF legal) 10 8 10 9 9 9.20 Lecture: could be part of a good session/panel
4015 Submissions/New frontiers in digital censorship and circumvention for Wikipedia users Deji Bryce Olukotun, Gustaf Björksten 10 9 10 8 10 9.40 workshop
4016 Submissions/Right to be forgotten and Wikipedia: A difficult relationship Marco Correa (User:Warko) 10 COI 7 7 7 7.75 lecture
4017 Submissions/Soliciting Data Donations: A Beginners Guide Andy Mabbett 10 7 7 8 8 8.00 discussion - bof/roundtable, 25 min +
4018 Submissions/Shining Light on Legal Threats to Free Knowledge Jacob Rogers, Aeryn Palmer, and Zhou Zhou (WMF legal) 10 8 10 9 8 9.00 panel, 55 min
4019 Submissions/The glue of the web - protecting the right to link Jan Gerlach (WMF) 10 9 9 8 8 8.80 lecture
4020 Submissions/Using the Wikipedia trademarks outside and within the Wikimedia movement Charles M. Roslof 10 8 7 9 9 8.60 lecture